The EU is attempting to downgrade the safety standing of wolves in Europe. Scientists say there are a lot of methods to co-exist with these creatures which are important for a wholesome ecosystem.
SCOTT DETROW, HOST:
This subsequent story begins with two girls with two very completely different tales. Ursula von der Leyen is the pinnacle of the European Fee. Valeria Rosselli is an Italian wildlife tour information. Each have misplaced a beloved pet to wolf assaults. The methods they responded, as NPR’s Ruth Sherlock experiences, takes us to the center of a battle unfolding over the longer term for wolves in Europe.
RUTH SHERLOCK, BYLINE: Beneath an almost full moon on September 1, 2022, a male wolf slipped right into a paddock within the nation hamlet of Burgdorf Beinhorn in Germany. He was following the scent of an aged chestnut pony named Dolly. She grew to become his subsequent meal.
(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)
URSULA VON DER LEYEN: (Talking German).
SHERLOCK: The issue is Dolly belonged to Ursula von der Leyen, the president of the European Fee.
(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)
UNIDENTIFIED REPORTER: (Talking German).
VON DER LEYEN: (Talking German).
SHERLOCK: A German media outlet BILD broadcast information of Dolly’s homicide. DNA samples had been taken from the horse’s carcass, which recognized the killer wolf as GW950m. He was already wished by others for preying on livestock. His protected standing was stripped, and he was placed on a kill listing.
(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)
UNIDENTIFIED REPORTER: (Talking German).
SHERLOCK: Then a yr later, Von der Leyen championed plans to scale back the safety standing for all wolves within the European Union.
(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)
VON DER LEYEN: I am speaking about massive predators and the menace they pose to our animals.
SHERLOCK: On this speech to farmers, she urged them to present examples of wolf assaults on livestock, to collect proof for the trigger.
(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)
VON DER LEYEN: This may then information additional our motion for wolf administration.
SHERLOCK: This relentless pursuit was observed in Brussels. The information outlet Politico known as it a private campaign in an article that quoted diplomats calling her deal with wolves, quote, “weird and pushy.”
Lots of of miles away, within the mountains of Italy’s Abruzzo, Lazio and Molise Nationwide Park, wildlife information Valeria Rosselli tells nature vacationers her personal story of private tragedy brought on by wolves.
VALERIA ROSSELLI: (Talking Italian).
SHERLOCK: It occurred to her canine Walco, a Czechoslovakian wolf canine. He would move the time exchanging howls from his backyard with the wild wolves throughout – not realizing, maybe, the hazard this put him in.
ROSSELLI: (Talking Italian).
SHERLOCK: In the future, 4 wolves jumped the fence. Walco was no match for them.
ROSSELLI: (Talking Italian).
SHERLOCK: However dropping her pet did not flip Rosselli in opposition to wolves. She now makes use of Walco’s story in her tour to advertise adaptation and coexistence with these animals.
ROSSELLI: (Talking Italian).
SHERLOCK: Rosselli says she and her neighbors discovered to not depart meals out for his or her canine and to maintain unattended pets indoors, and the wolf assaults stopped.
ROSSELLI: (Talking Italian).
SHERLOCK: She hopes that in instructing folks about wolves, she will be able to present them that coexistence is feasible with these creatures who, in an period of large decline of biodiversity, scientists say are important to sustaining wholesome ecosystems.
However these two tales of what occurred to Dolly and Walco and the way their house owners reacted displays a political battle that is unfolding over the way forward for wolves in Europe. The European Union spent hundreds of thousands serving to to safe the return of wolf populations. However in recent times, because the far-right has encroached into mainstream politics, this deal with nature has declined.
GAIA ANGELINI: Positively, there isn’t a scientific justification for weakening their safety.
SHERLOCK: Gaia Angelini leads Inexperienced Affect, one among a number of environmental teams now taking the European Fee to court docket over the choice to downgrade the protected standing of wolves. Lots of of scientists and specialists are backing their submission.
ANGELINI: And it has been signed by greater than 700 folks since, mainly, science is crystal clear on the truth that the populations of wolves in Europe are nonetheless in danger. Due to this fact, the best safety must be maintained.
SHERLOCK: As apex predators, wolves assist hold ecosystems in steadiness by holding populations of deer, wild boar and different hoofed animals in verify. They usually hold these populations wholesome too, looking the sick and stopping the unfold of illness. Angelini believes, sure, the expertise of dropping Dolly the horse doubtless impacted EU Fee President von der Leyen’s views. But in addition, that is politics.
ANGELINI: It is clearly instrumentalized (ph) for very short-sighted political curiosity.
SHERLOCK: Von der Leyen is from a right-wing occasion that advantages from the help of the farming foyer. Her workplace declined our request for an interview and shared as an alternative a press launch with a press release from the EU commissioner saying this modified EU regulation will, quote, “assist native authorities to actively handle wolf populations whereas defending each biodiversity and our rural livelihoods.”
(SOUNDBITE OF WOLF HOWLS)
SHERLOCK: However the conservation group, Io Non Ho Paura Del Lupo, or I am Not Terrified of the Wolf, who offered this recording of wolf howls, says capturing wolves shouldn’t be the most effective resolution to guard rural livelihoods.
(SOUNDBITE OF WOLF HOWLS)
FRANCESCO ROMITO: (Non-English language spoken).
SHERLOCK: Francesco Romito, the vp of Io Non Ho Paura Del Lupo, says they acknowledge breeders’ considerations about wolves killing livestock and assist them acquire the information and instruments they should shield their animals. Sturdy electrical fencing and canine just like the white abruzzo shepherd might be simpler than attempting to shoot wolves. And total, in actuality, relating to European livestock, wolves solely kill nearly half of one-tenth of 1%.
LUCA DE ROSA: (Talking Italian).
SHERLOCK: Farmer Luca de Rosa shrugs and says he actually does not care or take into consideration the wolves in his space. He is within the rural Italian Abruzzo province, the place wolves by no means went extinct, and so farmers have lengthy lived alongside them. Defending their flocks, for instance, by holding canine with them simply feels regular. Typically sheep die, however that is a part of the truth of dwelling in a rural space.
DE ROSA: (Talking Italian).
SHERLOCK: “The wolf is rather like different wild animals on this space. In the future he is right here, one other he is gone to a different a part of the mountain,” he says. “Why ought to we shoot them?” Ruth Sherlock, NPR Information, Abruzzo, Italy.
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)
Copyright © 2025 NPR. All rights reserved. Go to our web site terms of use and permissions pages at www.npr.org for additional info.
Accuracy and availability of NPR transcripts might differ. Transcript textual content could also be revised to appropriate errors or match updates to audio. Audio on npr.org could also be edited after its unique broadcast or publication. The authoritative file of NPR’s programming is the audio file.
